(607NewsNow) — In the heart of Ithaca’s Commons sits Benjamin Peters, a men’s clothing store founded in 1994, that has long been known for its dedication to quality menswear.

Over the past few years, under the leadership of Sam & Mickey by his side, the store has not just preserved its legacy, it has sharpened it. Through thoughtful expansion of services, a renewed focus on craftsmanship, and a deep commitment to authentic customer experience, they have taken an already respected business to new heights.

A Strong Foundation

Benjamin Peters has always prided itself on offering fine men’s clothing, sportswear, shoes and accessories. From its early days, the store built a reputation on excellent value, personal service, and tailoring.
When Sam & Mickey took over operations, they inherited that legacy, but they didn’t rest on it. Instead, they saw opportunities: ways to deepen the store’s commitment to fit, quality, and local distinction.

Enhancing Tailoring Services

One of the most notable upgrades has been a total overhaul of their in-house tailoring program. While tailoring had been part of Benjamin Peters‘ offerings in the past, they’ve brought the workshop back home with in-house custom services
•       Benjamin Peters was voted Finger Lakes’ Favorite tailor shop 2 years running, talent that ensures every garment fits not just well, but precisely, whether it’s a dress shirt, trousers, sport coat, or suit.
•       The normal turnaround is 1-2 weeks for standard tailoring jobs, with an option for express service if you need something faster.
•       The scope is broad: from basic hems and cuff adjustments to more complex operations like taking in the sides of sport coats. These are the kinds of finishing touches that separate the good from the great.
These enhancements have not only improved the utility of the store for customers but have reaffirmed Benjamin Peters‘ position in Ithaca as a place you go when you want clothing that fits you, not just off the rack. The consistency and attention to detail have built new trust.

Introducing “House made” accessories made in Ithaca

With the expansion of the tailoring team came the ability to make hand-made, locally made pieces such as satin-lined tote bags, and a limited collection of ties made right in the shop.

Why It Matters

What Sam and Mickey are doing isn’t just business growth, it’s stewardship. They are stewarding a legacy, while listening to what customers want today:
•       Personal service: Recognizing that style, fit, and accessory choices are deeply personal.
•       Quality over speed: Even as more stores chase fast fashion, Benjamin Peters is betting on enduring value.
•       Local identity: Maintaining roots in Ithaca, supporting local tailoring talent, being a part of the Commons, contributing to downtown life.
Customers are clearly noticing. Reviews often mention the attentive service, the fit, the way the staff helps achieve a look that feels authentic.

Looking Forward

If the past few years are any indication, Benjamin Peters under Sam and Mickey is just getting started. Possible growth areas that seem within reach:
•       Expanding their “house made” collection
•       Continuing to perfect the art of tailoring
•       Occasional in-house events: tie-making workshops, style consultations
•       Collaborations with local artisans for fabrics / limited-edition pieces